PoliticsTexas Gov. Greg Abbott Ends Onerous Truck Inspection Order...

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott Ends Onerous Truck Inspection Order Impeding International Commerce on the Mexican Border

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott


Earlier today, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott ended a system of onerous inspections he had previously imposed on trucks crossing into his state from Mexico. The official rationale for the inspections was the supposed need to curb cross-border drug smuggling and illegal migration. But, as Reason’s Fiona Harrigan explains, the inspections caused great harm for little, if any gain:

The enhanced inspections, which bolster efforts already carried out by Customs and Border Patrol (CBP), have brought traffic to a standstill in the name of stopping the illegal transportation of drugs and migrants. “We weren’t taken into consideration,” said Ernesto Gaytan, chair of the Texas Trucking Association (TXTA), telling Reuters that migrants rarely attempt to enter the U.S. on commercial trucks at ports of entry….

“Unfortunately, this new initiative duplicates existing screening efforts and leads to significant congestion, delaying the products Americans rely on from our largest trading partner, Mexico,” reads a statement from the TXTA. Mexico’s National Chamber of Freight Transport reported that its member companies were losing millions of dollars each day due to delays. The Texas International Produce Association implored Abbott to modify his policy, with CEO Dante Galeazzi writing that “U.S. trucking companies are losing money as they sit around for days with no loads to haul.” Galeazzi reported hearing “that a trucking company is refusing to send trucks south of San Antonio out of concern there will be no cargo available.” Perishable goods run the risk of spoiling during long waits in the Texas heat.

Far from being a localized issue, the delays imposed by Abbott’s new inspection measures have also irked federal border officials, who warn about broader supply chain challenges. CBP described recent wait times “exceeding five hours and commercial traffic dropping by as much as 60 percent,” noting that its officials already “comprehensively” inspect and clear vehicles to enter the U.S. “The strength of the American economy relies heavily on the efficient flow of cross-border commerce,” said CBP.

After an outcry by truckers and others, Abbott terminated the inspections. He has tried to claim victory by citing agreements reached with the governors of Mexican border states. But, in fact, as the Texas Tribune has documented, the agreements don’t include any significant provisions beyond what the Mexicans were already doing:

This strongly suggests that the inspections were more about grandstanding for the benefit of Abbott’s political base, than solving any genuine problem.

In addition, it is likely that they were also unconstitutional. The Dormant Commerce Clause of the Constitution restricts state regulations that impede interstate and foreign commerce. Most of the relevant legal precedents are about state laws that burden interstate commerce. But Supreme Court precedent makes clear that similar constraints apply to state regulation of international trade, which thereby infringes the “Dormant Foreign Commerce Clause.”

The legal doctrine here is complicated, and I am by no means expert on all of it. But I would tentatively say that Abbott’s inspection regime was a fairly obvious violation of the Dormant Foreign Commerce Clause. Supreme Court precedent is especially clear that the Dormant Commerce Clause forbids state regulations that  target international or interstate commerce or discriminate against it. The Abbott inspections focused exclusively on cross-border trade, and were explicitly intended to target it. No similarly onerous inspections were imposed on purely domestic trucking.

I welcome correction by Dormant Commerce Clause experts. But if I have this right, it looks like an easy case. The issue may be moot, as the inspections have ended. However, it could arise again if Abbott or another border-state governor decides to institute a similar policy in the future. It is also possible that truckers and others harmed by Abbott’s policies could sue for damages. The Supreme Court has ruled that Dormant Commerce Clause violations can sometimes give rise to damages lawsuits under 42 U.S.C. Section 1983.

Some conservative jurists, such as Supreme Court Justices Clarence Thomas and the late Antonin Scalia, have argued that the Dormant Commerce Clause doctrine lacks originalist support and should be abolished. If so, the neither Abbott’s policy nor anything else could violate it. I won’t try to assess the merits of this longstanding debate here, except to note that adopting Scalia Thomas’ position would require reversal of longstanding Supreme Court precedent.


Original Source Link

Latest News

U.S. monitoring high-altitude balloon over the west

The U.S. shot down a Chinese surveillance balloon in February 2023.US Department of Defense | Handout | Anadolu...

$30 billion RIA Platform Carson Group Approves To Offer Spot Bitcoin ETFs To Clients

Carson Group, a significant $30 billion registered investment adviser (RIA) platform, has recently announced its approval to offer...

Global cumulative shipments of 5G smartphones crossed 2B in less than five years, a faster adoption rate than 3G or 4G; Apple and Samsung...

Counterpoint Research: Global cumulative shipments of 5G smartphones crossed 2B in less than five years, a faster adoption...

Court Strikes Down California Ban on Possessing Billy Clubs

From Judge Roger Benitez's decision in Fouts v. Bonta(S.D. Cal.): This case is about a California law that...

Why do cats have bald spots in front of their ears?

Cats are known for their fastidious grooming; their soft, thick coats seem to require their constant attention. But...

Must Read

Metal Prices Are Soaring. So Is Metal Theft

Some people will go to extraordinary lengths to...

Women may benefit more from regular workouts than men

They say anything men can do, women can...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you