PoliticsOriginalism, Common Goodism, and Conservative Constitutionalism

Originalism, Common Goodism, and Conservative Constitutionalism


Earlier this month I noted Judge Bill Pryor’s recent Federalist Society lecture, “Against Living Common Goodism,” criticizing Harvard law professor Adrian Vermeule’s Common Good Constitutionalism. Professor Vermeule and Conor Casey of the University of Liverpool School of Law & Social Justice have now replied in an essay forthcoming in the Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy Per Curiam.  Here is the abstract from SSRN:

This short essay responds to several lectures and talks given by Chief Judge William Pryor Jr. of the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit critiquing common good constitutionalism. We demonstrate that the arguments advanced by Chief Judge Pryor in favor of originalism badly misfire, permit the very things Judge Pryor wants to rule out, and beg the critical questions about the classical tradition. In the end, they amount to little more than argument by slogan.

Meanwhile, Liberty Fund’s Law & Liberty site has posted “A Return to Classical  Law?”, a symposium on Vermeule’s book, with contributions from several noted scholars. These contributions are as follows:

Originalism for the Common Good
John O. McGinnis

A Common Good Requires a Common People
Jesse Merriam

Uncommonly Bad Constitutionalism
James M. Patterson

Policing Common Good Constitutionalism
James R. Rogers

Classical Historicism?
Paul Seaton

And so the discussion and debate continues.



Original Source Link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest News

UnitedHealth, CVS, Centene to lose Medicare star bonuses for 2023

For some companies, it is not the number of plans that received a high rating that's significant, but...

Judge Refuses To Admit Oath Keeper ‘Death Wish’ List Into Seditious Conspiracy Trial

In the most important J6th trial to date, U.S. District Court Judge Mehta refused to...

Save up to 50% on magnesium supplements in the Prime Early Access Sale

While we should all try to get most of our essential nutrients from whole foods, the right dietary...

7 Tips for Staying Organized With Your New Roommates

Living with roommates can be a lot of fun and save you money, but it can also get...

Iconic Easter Island Heads Suffer ‘Irreparable’ Damage After Massive Wildfire

Some of the famed stone heads of Easter Island have been damaged in a massive wildfire.“The moai are...

Shade Or No Shade?? King Charles’ Nickname For Meghan Markle Could Go Either Way…

King Charles III had quite the inneresting nickname for Meghan Markle! In her book, The New Royals, royal expert...

Must Read

- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you