PoliticsOriginalism, Common Goodism, and Conservative Constitutionalism

Originalism, Common Goodism, and Conservative Constitutionalism


Earlier this month I noted Judge Bill Pryor’s recent Federalist Society lecture, “Against Living Common Goodism,” criticizing Harvard law professor Adrian Vermeule’s Common Good Constitutionalism. Professor Vermeule and Conor Casey of the University of Liverpool School of Law & Social Justice have now replied in an essay forthcoming in the Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy Per Curiam.  Here is the abstract from SSRN:

This short essay responds to several lectures and talks given by Chief Judge William Pryor Jr. of the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit critiquing common good constitutionalism. We demonstrate that the arguments advanced by Chief Judge Pryor in favor of originalism badly misfire, permit the very things Judge Pryor wants to rule out, and beg the critical questions about the classical tradition. In the end, they amount to little more than argument by slogan.

Meanwhile, Liberty Fund’s Law & Liberty site has posted “A Return to Classical  Law?”, a symposium on Vermeule’s book, with contributions from several noted scholars. These contributions are as follows:

Originalism for the Common Good
John O. McGinnis

A Common Good Requires a Common People
Jesse Merriam

Uncommonly Bad Constitutionalism
James M. Patterson

Policing Common Good Constitutionalism
James R. Rogers

Classical Historicism?
Paul Seaton

And so the discussion and debate continues.



Original Source Link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest News

What to Look For When Touring Homes

Touring homes can be a thrilling experience, especially if you’re a first-time homebuyer. However, you can easily get...

Queen Elizabeth Makes First Public Appearance In Weeks At Horse Show

LONDON (AP) — Queen Elizabeth II attended the Royal Windsor Horse Show on Friday, watching her beloved equines...

Alexander Skarsgård And Dane DeHaan Will Play Reluctant Tiger Hunters In The Tiger

Aronofsky is producing "The Tiger" through his Protozoa Pictures label, and Brad Pitt's Plan B Entertainment is also...

Emirates Airline, stung by soaring fuel prices, posts $1.1 billion dollar loss

Aircraft operated by Emirates, at Dubai International Airport in the United Arab Emirates.Christopher Pike | Bloomberg | Getty...

Major Increase In Bitcoin Trading Volume

The below is an excerpt from a recent edition of Bitcoin Magazine Pro, Bitcoin Magazine's premium markets newsletter....

Europe battles to secure steel following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine

Before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the Azovstal steelworks in Mariupol was a major exporter, its steel used in...

Must Read

Ukraine’s Scientists Keep Working In Defiance Of Russian Invasion

Anton Vlaschenko often hears shelling outside his office...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you