PoliticsIs This Legal Doctrine a Garlic Press?

Is This Legal Doctrine a Garlic Press?

Have you ever heard a legal scholar criticize a doctrine because it does several different things, but it isn’t really good at any one of those things? That kind of criticism of a doctrine is much less common from a judge. Why is that? If you want the answer to these questions, there’s a Green Bag article I wrote a few years ago called On Doctrines That Do Many Things. It starts this way:

Every kitchen has two kinds of tools. Some of these tools do many things well, like a chef’s knife. Other tools do only one thing, but they are meant to do that one thing exceedingly well, like a garlic press. The same distinction appears in legal doctrines. Some doctrines do one thing and are meant to do it very well. Others do many different things. They serve multiple functions, though perhaps all imperfectly.

Original Source Link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest News

Massive Protest Rocks The Supreme Court For Second Day After Roe Is Overturned

The protesters aren’t going away, and their numbers seem to be growing on the second day after the...

What is non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT)?

It can be a secret weapon for those with weight loss goals, but for many people the answer...

'I decided to build my own camp': 14,000-SF Poconos home with indoor Olympic-length pool lists for $3.5M

Located on 73 acres, the estate also includes a home theater, outdoor kitchen and a sprawling gym. ...

Deadly Earthquake Devastates Afghans Already Reeling From Poverty

GAYAN, Afghanistan (AP) — Afghanistan’s deadly earthquake this week struck one of the poorest corners of a country...

The Umbrella Academy Season 3 Ending Explained: A Kugel-What-Now?

Basically, yes ... we think. The Hotel, it turns out, is protected by an otherworldly defender: a samurai...

World Health Organization says monkeypox is not a global health emergency right now

The World Health Organization on Saturday said the rapid spread of monkeypox across dozens of nations does not...

Must Read

- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you