PoliticsShort and Sweet Rejection of Anti-Libel TRO Request

Short and Sweet Rejection of Anti-Libel TRO Request

[ad_1]

From Carroll v. Namecheap, Inc., decided yesterday by Judge Lewis Kaplan (S.D.N.Y.) but just docketed this morning:

Plaintiff claims that the defendant hosts a website that has posted “images of Mr. Carroll along with a litany of [unspecified] false and defamatory allegations about him” and, in  addition, that the website posts “audio of a surreptitiously recorded phone conversation between Mr. Carroll and his ex-wife [obtained] in violation of Florida eavesdropping law.” He now seeks a temporary restraining order barring defendant from “from hosting and publishing content on the website” and a preliminary injunction to the same effect. The application is without merit for a number of reasons including but not necessarily limited to the following:

1. As far as the docket discloses, the defendant has not been served.

2. It is questionable whether the complaint adequately alleges facts that, if true, would
establish personal jurisdiction over the defendant, which is alleged to be a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business in Arizona. Indeed, plaintiff claims to be a resident of Florida.

3. A temporary restraining order barring the defendant from hosting and publishing
[unspecified] content on the web site would be a presumptively unconstitutional prior restraint violating the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and probably also the Due Process Clause. See, e.g., Nebraska Press Ass’n v. Stuart, 427 U.S. 539, 556-62 (1976); New York Times Co. v. United States, 403 U.S. 713, 714 (1971).

Accordingly, the motion for an order to show cause and a temporary restraining order is denied. Plaintiff may move by notice of motion for a preliminary injunction, bearing in mind that he faces a possibly insurmountable task.

I think the lawsuit against Namecheap, which is only the host and not the author of the allegedly tortious site, is also barred by 47 U.S.C. § 230; but the judge did say, “a number of reasons including but not necessarily limited to ….” For more on the case, see the Complaint.

The post Short and Sweet Rejection of Anti-Libel TRO Request appeared first on Reason.com.

[ad_2]

Original Source Link

Latest News

Inside Meghan Markle & Prince Harrys New Chapter Amid Her Estranged Fathers CSAM Arrest – Perez Hilton

Not the start to the holiday season anyone would want. Meghan Markle is facing a uniquely challenging time as disturbing...

Injected cadaver skin: the latest anti-aging product in the Korean skincare frenzy

IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.Now PlayingInjected cadaver skin: the...

Cops Are Pushing Extremely Corny GTA VI Slop

Listening to the in-game radio stations while you cruise around in Grand Theft Auto VI, you might hear a...

This years El Niño is unlike any other on record

View Original Article Here

XMR1 Exploit: Bitquery Traces $13.5M in Suspicious Token Sales

A wrapped version of Monero (XMR) plunged more than 99% on Hyperliquid on Friday after a wallet that received...

Must Read

- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you