Greetings gentle readers and welcome to another installment of the Sunday Morning Movie. Today it’s a tale of superstition and repression, The Witch Hunt:
and next week’s film, The Magician:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1p5ptG7hdM&t=12s
Reviews of The Witch Hunt:
Letterboxd says:
A tale that eschews any hysteria for a sombre, almost detached, depiction of a woman falling foul of the superstitions of 16th century Norway. That the titular investigation proves to be little more than arrogant men acting on the suspicions of exhausted villagers is not new, but what is interesting is the strongly coded suggestion that our lead’s lover suffers badly from epilepsy. There’s one mention of him having the “falling sickness” and we see him twitch in a manner concordant with the diagnosis multiple times. What emerges from this, and how it frames our lead’s downfall, is a sad portrait of how inner difference can be demonised even by those who possess it, who understand its existence within them but cannot name it or grasp its causes. Thus the only options become; I am undeserving, or I have been bewitched. And in a climate where the threat of eternal damnation is very real (as befitting the severe sermon midway through the film), it is no surprise that most people turn that shame to an outwards source. For all the dangers of the therapeutic culture we now live in (which I’ll be watching later today with If I Had Legs…), we can at least acknowledge that there has been some development since the days of burning people for spurious possession.
and
I still find the texture of these small Euro period piece dramas compelling. Unbelievably beautiful to look at and unbelievably frustrating to watch unfold. Not a particularly novel plot, witchcraft accusations used as an excuse to abuse and kill women who step out of line, but here no one is allowed to have what they want and everyone gets ground into the Earth. Judging from Breien’s other work, I imagine she isn’t just commenting on 17th century Norwegian life. History repeats and beheading isn’t the only way to punish. Don’t read the synopsis on here because it tells you the entire plot of the movie save for the epilogue, which honestly was the only unnecessary element of the film. Criminally underseen visual feast.
My take:
A brutal, but beautiful, film. I do love historical realism, despite my old history professor’s warnings about popular historical interpretations. The Witch Hunt is a snapshot of 16th. century Norway. The picture is pretty grim, especially if you were a woman. If you were an outspoken woman, as the heroine of the story is, things were really bad. If you had land the king wanted to get his hands on, well…⭐⭐.
Director: Anja Breien
Writer: Anja Breien
Plot (Spoilers!):
Eli is a young Norwegian girl living in Norway in the 1600’s. Her husband has abandoned her. She has moved on and now seeks to live on her family’s ancestral farm.
At first things seem good. She meets a handsome young man, Aslak. She raises livestock and harvests herbs. But things are about to take a turn for the worse.
Through a series of unfortunate events, she is branded a witch. She resists her oppressors as best she can, but it’s a losing battle. In the final scenes, she is being transported by boat back across the water she arrived from, on her way to a grisly death.
***
Bonuses:
The Miracle of Flight. A cutout animation by Terry Gilliam
Terry Gilliam cutout animation – the Miracle of Flight. In the style of Monty Pythons Flying Circus but made seperately.
Central Problem in the Philosophy of Mathematics
A clip of Bryan Magee and Hilary Putnam discussing the central problem in the philosophy of mathematics: what mathematics is about and whether it is invented or discovered. This is from a program on the philosophy of science in the 1977 series on Modern Philosophy with Bryan Magee called Men of Ideas.
How Does it Fit the World?
A clip of Bryan Magee and Hilary Putnam discussing the central problem in the philosophy of mathematics: how does it fit the world? This is from a program on the philosophy of science in the 1977 series on Modern Philosophy with Bryan Magee called Men of Ideas.
‘The Father Thing’ by Philip K. Dick
‘The Father Thing’ by Philip K. Dick is a story about humans being replaced by aliens. It poses the question: What would you do if someone you loved suddenly turned into a monster. The story was originally published in 1954. More recently, in 2017, writer-director Michael Dinner adapted the story as an episode of the TV series ‘Electric Dreams’, starring Greg Kinnear as the Father.
Anthony Burgess — Lots of Fun at Finnegans Wake (1973)
Anthony Burgess discusses James Joyce’s novel Finnegans Wake (1939); he sings “The Ballad of Perrse O’Reilly”
David Bentley Hart – Does Consciousness Defeat Materialism?
What would it take for consciousness to defeat materialism or physicalism? This is the worldview that only the physical is real, which is the dominant view of scientists and philosophers. Here’s what it would take: our inner awareness, our experience of what things feel like, could not be explained by physical brain alone That’s it. A tall order, though.



